Why is plant and trees not considered as pritivikaya
In Jainism, plants and trees are not counted as Pṛthvīkāy (earth-bodied beings) because:
- Clear scriptural classification of 5 kāy (bodies)
Jain Āgams and later texts divide one-sensed (ekendriya) jīvas into five main groups: - Pṛthvīkāy – earth-bodied - Apkāy – water-bodied - Teukāy – fire-bodied - Vāyukāy – air-bodied - Vanaspatikāy – plant-bodied (all plants, trees, grass, crops, etc.) ( jainknowledge.com)
So, plants and trees are specifically put in Vanaspatikāy, not in Pṛthvīkāy.
- Basis of classification = type of body, not location
- Pṛthvīkāy = jīvas whose body is of earth-substance (soil, stone, metals, etc., in natural, undivided state when enlivened by a soul). ( jainknowledge.com) - Vanaspatikāy = jīvas whose body is of plant-substance (stem, leaves, roots, fruits, trees). ( jainknowledge.com)
Even if a tree is growing in the earth, its own body is not earth, it is plant-material. So it cannot be called Pṛthvīkāy.
- Ahimsā viewpoint
- Harming earth (soil, stone, etc.) = himsā of Pṛthvīkāy. - Cutting a tree or leaf = himsā of Vanaspatikāy. Jain ethics need these categories to know which jīva is harmed and how serious the violence is.
- No Digambar–Śvetāmbara difference here
Both traditions accept the same five dravya-kāy classifications, and both put plants/trees under Vanaspatikāy, not Pṛthvīkāy.