I've a family member, who's elder and not on good terms with me, he often scolds harshly, sometimes when I feel agitated I reply back strongly. It so happened once, he scolded me harshly and I replied back with full vigour, which had another relative of m
In Jain dharma, what happened with you is very understandable, and also very meaningful spiritually. Let’s see it step by step in simple terms.
1. What actually happened – in Jain view
- An elder scolded you harshly → this became a cause (nimitta) for krodh (anger) to rise in your mind.
- In that moment, you answered back with full force → this is:
- A relative cried seeing you speak harshly to an elder → this shows:
So, at that time:
- Internally: disturbance, agitation, anger, then later guilt and fear.
- Externally: harsh words, hurt feelings, damaged relations.
In Jain terms, in that first phase, there was:
- Āsrava – inflow of karmas, especially due to anger and harsh speech.
- Bandha – bondage of new karmas because the passions were intense.
2. Your guilt and worry – what does it show?
After they left, you felt:
- Guilt: “I was wrong, I spoke too harshly.”
- Worry: “If this spreads, relatives may stop engaging with me.”
From a Jain perspective, guilt has two sides:
- Healthy side (spiritual)
- You recognized your mistake. - You did not justify it inside (“They started it, so I’m right”) – instead, you felt, “I shouldn’t have done this.” - This shows vivek (discrimination between right and wrong) is alive in you. - This is the beginning of pratikraman bhav – turning back from wrong.
- Unhealthy side (worldly fear)
- Worry about image, reputation, relations. - This is more about lok-lajjā (fear of what people will say/think). - Jain dharma does not deny this, but it says the main focus should be on inner correction rather than only social image.
So your guilt actually means:
- Your conscience is awake.
- You have sensitivity (sahaj komalta) in your heart.
- You are capable of uttam kshamā (higher forgiveness) and vinaya (humility) if guided properly.
You can read more about the Jain concept of forgiveness (uttam kshamā) here:
3. Your crying and apology – spiritually, this is very important
You went downstairs, cried, and apologized.
In Jain dharma, this is very close to the process of alochana–pratikraman–pratyākhyān:
- Alochana (confession in front of someone / oneself)
- You internally accepted that “I was wrong.” - Tears came – this is a form of inner softness (mārdav). - Crying itself is not weakness; here it shows remorse and breaking of ego.
- Pratikraman (turning back from the wrong)
- You did not stay in your anger. - You actively went and said sorry. - This is exactly the practical form of pratikraman in daily life: - Realizing → Regretting → Returning (correcting).
- Pratyākhyān (resolve not to repeat) – even if not verbal
- The very fact that you are now thinking deeply about it and asking “What does all this mean?” shows: - You want to avoid such behaviour in future. - A sankalp (inner resolve) is arising: “Next time I should not react like this.”
According to Jain philosophy, such honest repentance and apology:
- Reduces the intensity of already bound karma.
- Stops more intense negative karma from being bound.
- Softens future relations and future situations.
So spiritually, you did two opposite things in one episode:
- First part: anger, harsh speech → karmic bondage increased.
- Second part: guilt, softness, apology → karmic intensity reduced, inner purity increased.
Both are meaningful; you are learning.
4. What about feeling “I was harsh to an elder”?
In Jain dharma, respect to elders (guru, parents, senior family) is considered a form of vinaya – a great virtue.
So when you feel:
- “I spoke badly to an elder, this is very wrong,”
- You have sanskār of vinaya inside.
- You are not comfortable when you go against that value.
However, one more thing is important:
- The elder’s behaviour may actually be unfair or hurtful.
- Jain dharma does not say, “Accept every injustice silently.”
- It says: if you have to set a boundary or speak up, do it without krodh, without himsa in words, as much as possible.
So:
- Your pain is valid.
- Your reaction style (harsh scolding) is what needs refinement.
5. What you can learn from this incident (Jain way)
(a) See it as a mirror, not a label
Do not stamp yourself as “I am a bad person.” Instead think:
- “This incident showed me how strong my anger can become.”
- “It also showed me I have the capacity to feel sorry and apologize.”
In Jain dharma, you are not your one incident. You are a soul covered by karmas and habits. Incidents are opportunities for udaya (fruition of karma) and learning.
(b) Strengthen daily kshama–bhav (forgiveness attitude)
Ask yourself every day:
- “If this elder scolds me today, how will I respond as a Jain sadhak?”
- Mentally rehearse:
This is practicing uttam kshamā in small, practical ways.
You can read a simple explanation of uttam kshamā here:
(c) Formalize your repentance (inner pratikraman)
When you remember that scene, instead of only feeling heavy, do this mentally:
- Accept: “Yes, I did vachan-himsa, I hurt an elder and another relative.”
- Bow internally to the soul of that elder and the crying relative:
- “Jo jo mithyā-darshan, jnāna, chāritra se, vachan se, mann se, kāya se, tamne dukh pahuñchyu hoy, te badhā mate huṁ antim bhav thi kshamā māngu chu. Michchhami Dukkadam.”
- Resolve: “I will try my best not to repeat such harshness. If anger rises, I will at least control my tongue.”
Even if you do this silently, it has value.
(d) About your fear: “relatives will stop engaging me”
From Jain angle:
- This is a worldly consequence of our behaviour – and we cannot deny it.
- But:
Over time:
- If you consistently show softness, respect, and patience,
- Remember: Your true gain is inner purification, even if some relations take time to heal.
6. In essence, what does this whole episode mean?
Summarizing in Jain terms:
- Your anger and harsh words
- Show your current karmic tendencies (kashaya). - Caused vachan-himsa and karmic bondage.
- Your guilt, crying, and apology
- Show your inner sensitivity, vivek, and humility. - Are a form of pratikraman, reducing the intensity of the karmas.
- Spiritually
- This incident is like a lesson given by your own karma: - “See where you fall. See that you can rise again.” - It is an invitation to practice uttam kshamā, vinaya, and samata (equanimity) more consciously.
- Practically
- Next time, try to: - Pause before reacting. - Lower your volume, soften your words. - If needed, later express your point calmly, not in the heat of the moment. - Keep the habit of seeking forgiveness when you slip.
If you keep using such incidents for inner correction rather than only outer blame, this same painful memory becomes a turning point in your spiritual growth according to Jain dharma.