At times when I fail Or my expectations fail,i start blaming dharma, (when I scored less marks, when I was beaten ,scolded by teachers parents etc) I think despite my faith,this Or that bad has happened etc ,my faith gets shaken, while I also have a thoug
You are observing yourself very honestly. That itself is a big spiritual strength.
I’ll do three things:
- Explain what Samyaktva (Samyak‑darshan) is and its types in simple language.
- Give practical “signs / checklists” so you can roughly see where you stand.
- Directly answer your specific points: doubt, anger, laziness, blaming dharma, dream, etc.
You can also read more here: Samyak‑darshan & Ratnatraya Gunasthān (14 stages) Eight aṅgas of Samyak‑drishti
---
1. What is Samyaktva (Samyak‑darshan)?
In Jain dharma:
- Samyaktva = right faith / right vision.
- It is clear, deep conviction in:
- It is inner turning of the soul toward truth, not just outer rituals.
Both Digambar and Shvetambar accept this same basic meaning.
---
2. Stages related to Samyaktva (Gunasthān)
Jain dharma describes 14 gunasthān – spiritual stages. In short (relevant ones only):
- Mithyā‑drishti – completely wrong belief.
- Sāsvādana Samyag‑drishti – just a taste of right faith, then it goes.
- Samyak‑mithyā‑drishti – mixed: sometimes right, sometimes wrong belief.
- Avirata Samyag‑drishti – right faith, but no real vows / renunciation yet (no virati).
- Desha‑virata – shravak with partial vows.
- Pramatta‑virata, 7. Apramatta‑virata, etc. – higher and higher control, then monkhood, then keval‑jnan, etc.
From the 4th gunasthān upward, there is Samyaktva (right belief) in different strengths and with different levels of vows and passions.
---
3. Types of Samyaktva (as often described)
In both traditions, you will frequently see these 3 main types of samyak‑darshan:
- Aupaśamika Samyaktva
- Due to suppression of Moha (Mohaniya karma), not full destruction. - Feels like: strong faith for some time, then it can fade or shake.
- Kṣayopaśamika Samyaktva
- Mixed: some part of deluding karma destroyed, some suppressed. - More stable than aupaśamika, but still not 100% permanent.
- Kṣāyika Samyaktva
- Mohaniya karma responsible for wrong belief fully destroyed. - This is permanent, unshakeable right faith; no fall back to mithyātva.
Also, some texts speak of Sāsvādana Samyaktva (taste of right faith) near change of stages – this is very short‑lived, just a “taste”.
---
4. Eight aṅgas (characteristics) of true Samyak‑drishti
Traditionally, right faith has 8 limbs (aṅga).
- Niśaṅkitā – no doubt in tattvas and true dharma.
- Nikāṅkṣitā – no worldly expectation from dharma (not doing dharma for marks, money, health, etc.).
- Nirvicikitsā – no disgust / shame / aversion for Jin‑agya, sadhus, practices.
- Amūḍha‑drishti – not confused by wrong teachers, miracles, fear, etc.
- Upagūhana – protect and cover faults of fellow followers with empathy.
- Sthiti‑karaṇa – help others stay firm in right faith.
- Vātsalya – deep affection for those walking on dharma.
- Prabhāvanā – you like to honor, spread, and support true Jain dharma.
The more steadily these 8 appear, the stronger and purer the Samyaktva.
---
5. Applying this to what you described
You mentioned:
- Strong faith in Panch Parmeshthi; you don’t worship other devs.
- Often spontaneous samveg (intense desire for moksh).
- Nirved (disgust towards samsār) – “in and out”.
- Anukampā (compassion) for sansārī jiv.
- Aasthā in Jain tattvas, with some occasional doubts.
- Sometimes strong bhakti, sometimes very low.
- Blaming dharma when marks are low, when scolded, etc.
- Laziness / pramād – you do samayik etc. only when pushed.
- Shyness / discomfort when people stare at sadhus and you.
- A period of intense anger and violent thoughts toward a teacher; later deep regret and asking forgiveness mentally.
- A dream where you chanted Navkar when attacked.
Let’s map this against the qualities:
a) Your positive signs of Samyaktva‑tendency
- Anukampā, samveg, nirved, aasthā – these are very close to:
- You do not accept or worship non‑Jain devs, and you clearly accept Jin‑vani as true – this shows the direction of your vision is right.
- You feel regret for violent thoughts and seek forgiveness – this is very important. It shows:
- You like bhakti, even when lazy – so there is inner respect and love for dharma, not hatred.
All this is not the mentality of a hard Mithyā‑drishti who rejects Jain tattva. It suggests a strong pull toward Samyaktva.
b) Your obstacles and what they mean
- Blaming dharma when things go wrong
- This shows disturbance in Nikāṅkṣitā and Niśaṅkitā. - Somewhere inside, there is an expectation: “Because I have faith / did puja / did this, my worldly result should be good.” - But dharma is not a guarantee of marks, praise, or physical protection. Dharm = purification of karma and soul, not a business deal for worldly success. - This is a very common weakness even in many shravaks; it doesn’t mean you have no Samyaktva, but that your Samyaktva is not yet steady and pure.
- Laziness (pramād) and doing dharm only when pushed
- This affects charitra, not only darshan. - Even a Samyag‑drishti can have pramād until higher gunasthān. - So this alone does not disprove Samyaktva, but it blocks your growth.
- Occasional small doubts, slight shyness, dislike when people stare at you with sadhus
- These show that Nirvicikitsā and Amūḍha‑drishti are not yet full and stable. - But they are small waves; they become dangerous only if you turn away from dharma because of them. You are not doing that.
- Violent thoughts toward your teacher (even for years)
- Having such thoughts is a form of krodha‑kasāy (anger‑passion) under Mohaniya karma. - A right‑faith person can still have strong kasāy up to a point. - The key questions are: - Did you feel it is correct to kill? You did not; you later regretted. - Did you try to actually do it? No. - Did you eventually see it as sinful and wrong, seek forgiveness, and want to leave such bhāva? Yes.
So this is not proof that you lack Samyaktva; it shows strong past karma of anger and low control, but also a living conscience.
---
6. So, what type of Samyaktva might be there?
We must be very clear:
- Exact gunasthān and exact Samyaktva‑type of a person is perfectly known only to a Kevali (omniscient).
- Any human or our own judgment can only be approximate.
Based only on what you shared, in simple terms:
- You do not appear like a full Mithyā‑drishti (1st gunasthān), because:
- At the same time, your faith shakes, you blame dharma, you have expectations from dharma, and you have intense kasāy and pramād.
So you are likely somewhere around:
- Sāsvādana / Samyak‑mithyātva / Avirata Samyag‑drishti zone (2nd–4th gunasthān) –
This corresponds, in simple words, to:
- Aupaśamika or Kṣayopaśamika Samyaktva‑tendencies – faith that comes strong and then weakens, mixed with laziness and worldly attraction.
Don’t be disheartened by this. For most shravaks, this is normal and is in fact a good stage because from here, true progress is very possible and fast, if you work on it.
---
7. Can a Samyag‑drishti have such bad thoughts?
You asked: > “Can a Samyaktvi really get such thoughts?”
Answer in Jain siddhānta:
- Yes, until higher stages, a Samyag‑drishti can still have:
- The difference is:
So your strong regret and inner apology to your teacher is actually more important than the earlier violent thought. It shows Jin‑darshan is working within you.
---
8. Important correction: blaming dharma vs. law of karma
When marks are less, or you are beaten, scolded, etc., a thought comes:
> “Despite my faith, this bad happened. What is the use of dharma?”
From Jain view:
- Dharma is not a shield that blocks all painful karmas from giving result.
- Old karma must give its result. Even Tirthankars face the result of old karmas (like injuries, insults, etc.).
- The benefit of dharma is:
So when you suffer and then blame dharma, it means:
- You are mixing dharma with worldly success.
- With practice, shift this attitude to:
This shift is a major step toward purer Samyaktva.
---
9. How to strengthen and stabilize your Samyaktva
To move from “sometimes strong, sometimes weak” faith toward steady Samyaktva, do small but regular things:
- Daily Namokar with understanding
- Not mechanical; feel: - Arihant – pure, vitarag ideal; - Siddha – final goal; - Acharya – discipline; - Upadhyaya – scriptural wisdom; - Sadhu – living example.
- Short but sincere Samayik
- Even 20–30 minutes a day. - Focus: “I am soul, separate from body, marks, insult, praise.”
- Anupreksha (reflections) – especially:
- Anitya – everything worldly (marks, body, praise, insult) is temporary. - Asrava / Bandha – whenever you get angry, you are adding new chains. - Moksh – my real aim.
- Pratikraman and Alochana
- Honestly recall in the evening: - “Where did I blame dharma today?” - “Where did I get violent thoughts, hatred, jealousy?” - Bow mentally, ask forgiveness, and resolve not to repeat.
- Gradual control of kasāy
- When you feel anger rising, repeat internally: - “This is my own old karma result, not this person’s fault alone.” - Even if anger comes, try to shorten its duration a little each time.
- Reduce expectations from dharma
- If something good happens after puja, don’t think: “See, I did puja, so got this.” - Just think: “Whatever comes is my karma; puja purifies my soul.”
- Stay close to satsang and swādhyāy
- Listen / read about Samyak‑darshan, Gunasthān, Mohaniya karma etc. - For example, learning about Mithyātva vs Samyaktva will clarify your doubts.
---
10. About your dream with Navkar
In your dream, when attacked, your spontaneous reaction was to chant Navkar Mantra, and the demon left.
- Jain texts consider such spontaneous remembrance of Arihant / Mantra in crisis as a good sign of deep sanskār.
- It does not “prove” a certain gunasthān, but it shows:
This is a very encouraging sign.
---
11. In one line: Where you stand and what to do
From your own description:
- You have real Samyaktva‑tendencies: faith in tattvas, Panch Parmeshthi, samveg, nirved, anukampā.
- But your Samyaktva is not yet fully steady, pure, and expectation‑free.
- Anger, laziness, slight doubt, blaming dharma, and worldly attraction show that Mohaniya karma is still strong, which is normal for a progressing shravak.
Your work now is not to obsess about: > “Am I 3rd or 4th gunasthān? Aupaśamika or Kṣayopaśamika?”
Your work is to gently but firmly:
- Deepen Niśaṅkitā (remove doubt),
- Remove Nikāṅkṣitā (stop worldly expectations from dharma),
- Strengthen Nirvicikitsā (no shame in following dharma publicly),
- Maintain Anukampā, Vātsalya, Prabhāvanā.
As these 8 aṅgas become stronger and more stable in you, your Samyaktva will clearly become purer and more permanent, and the ups‑and‑downs you described will slowly reduce.
Jai Jinendra.