Jain Knowledge
Menu
  • JainGPT
  • Jain Directory
    • Jain Tirthsthaans
    • Jain Sangeetkars
    • Jain Pandits
    • Jain Acharya
    • Jain Businessman
  • Jain Media
    • Jain Stavan
    • Jain Pachkhan
    • Jain Stories
    • Jain Sutras
    • Jain Facts / Concepts
  • Advertise with us
Jain Knowledge
login Register

Get In Touch

phone
info@jainknowledge.com

online support

phone
Mumbai

India

  • Home
  • Jain Questions
  • what is the difference between questions asked by Skandaka and kalashyaveshi putra to Mahavir Bhagwan
  • author Posted by
    Jain Follower

    what is the difference between questions asked by Skandaka and kalashyaveshi putra to Mahavir Bhagwan

    10 months ago 180

    Here is the basic difference in very simple words:

    1) Questions of Skandaka (Parivrajaka monk) to Bhagwan Mahavir

    • Type of questions:
    Very deep darshanik (philosophical) doubts.
    • Main subject:
    Nature of the universe and soul – whether they are finite or infinite. For example, in the Bhagavati Sutra we see questions like: - Is the loka (universe) finite or infinite? - Is the jiva (soul) finite or infinite? - Is moksha finite or infinite? - Is the siddha (liberated soul) finite or infinite?
    • Purpose:
    To understand reality itself – the structure of loka, jiva, moksha – and Bhagwan Mahavir answers by explaining from different standpoints (dravya, kshetra, kaal, bhav – substance, space, time, modes). So Skandaka’s enquiry is mainly about metaphysics and anekantvaad (many-sided reality).

    ---

    2) Questions of Kalāsyaveśi-putra (Kalashyaveshi’s son) to Bhagwan’s elder disciples

    The story is usually told like this (in short):

    • Kalāsyaveśi’s son (or a householder in Kalasyaveshi’s house, depending on version) had been doing Samayik again and again.
    • One day he asks the sthavirs/elders (and through them, it is linked to Mahavir’s teaching):
    - “I have done so many samayiks – have I really done samayik?” - “What is true samayik?” - “What is the real meaning of samayik?”

    The elders answer in the spirit of Mahavir’s teaching:

    • Real samayik is not just sitting for 48 minutes or outward posture.
    • Real samayik = staying in the nature of the soul (atma‑swabhav), free from raag‑dvesh (attachment and aversion).
    • So his questions are mainly about spiritual practice: “What is right samayik, how many real samayiks have I actually done?”

    ---

    3) Core difference between their questions

    • Skandaka:
    - Asks about the nature of the universe, soul, moksha, siddha (finite/infinite). - Focus: Philosophical / cosmological understanding (tattva‑jnan). - Level: Very intellectual and metaphysical.
    • Kalāsyaveśi-putra:
    - Asks about his own practice of samayik. - Focus: Spiritual conduct and inner state – “Am I really doing it correctly? What is its true meaning?” - Level: Very practical and sadhana‑oriented.

    In short:

    • Skandaka’s questions: “What is this universe and soul really like (finite or infinite)?”
    • Kalāsyaveśi-putra’s questions: “What is real samayik, and have my samayiks been true or only external?”

    Both are beautiful in their own way: Skandaka seeks right understanding of reality, Kalāsyaveśi-putra seeks right practice in daily sadhana.

    About Jain Knowledge

    JainGPT by JainKnowledge.com is India’s first AI-powered platform dedicated entirely to Jainism. Here, you can ask any question related to Jain Dharma — from rituals and history to philosophy and daily practices — and receive instant, accurate answers rooted in Jain principles.

    Our mission is to make Jain knowledge accessible to all, especially the next generation, through the power of technology. Whether you're a curious student or a lifelong seeker, JainGPT is your trusted digital guide for all things Jain.

    Authentic Jain knowledge, made simple and accessible for every generation.
    Follow Us
    Facebook ↗ Instagram ↗

    Stay connected for Jain knowledge, insights and community updates.

    Jain Knowledge

    JainGPT by JainKnowledge.com is India’s first AI-powered platform dedicated entirely to Jainism. Ask questions related to Jain Dharma, rituals, history, philosophy and daily practices, and receive answers rooted in Jain principles.

    Explore
    • JainGPT
    • Jain Directory
    • Jain Media
    • Advertise With Us
    • Disclaimer
    Our Mission

    Our mission is to make Jain knowledge accessible to all, especially the next generation, through the power of technology. Whether you're a curious student or a lifelong seeker, JainGPT is your trusted digital guide for all things Jain.

    info@jainknowledge.com Online support
    Mumbai India

    Copyright © 2026 Jain Knowledge

    Created by Katalyst Corp.