If our immunity is weak or we take medicines to cure diseases which kills the pathogen so does that mean we are doing paap
In Jain dharma, this is understood with a few key principles:
- Basic rule: avoid unnecessary himsa, accept inevitable himsa
- Total non‑violence (no harm to any jiva) is the ideal of monks. - For householders, scriptures clearly accept that some violence (sanjogī / ārambhaj himsa – arising from living, earning, protecting life) is inevitable. - The vow is: do not do intentional, careless, or excessive violence, and keep reducing even necessary violence over time.
- Killing microorganisms vs intention
- Medicines (antibiotics, etc.) do kill countless tiny jivas (nigod, etc.). From the dravyārth (material) point of view, this is himsa. - But from the bhāvārth / intention point of view: - Your aim is not cruelty or pleasure. - Your aim is to protect a life, reduce suffering, and maintain health to follow dharma. - Jain acharyas repeatedly say: karma mainly binds through intention with passions (kashāy) – anger, pride, deceit, greed. - So if you take medicine with: - awareness (“this involves some himsa, I should be careful”), - gratitude, and - compassion (for self/others, to be able to do good), then the pap is very light and often mixed with punya (because you are preserving life and reducing suffering).
- Is it pap to take medicine?
- If you carelessly consume, harm others, or misuse medicines (e.g., killing animals for experiments for fun, or overusing when not needed), that is more pap. - Taking necessary treatment to save your life or recover health so you can live a dharmic life is generally accepted and not considered a major pap. - It falls under the type of “aparihārya himsa” – unavoidable violence in worldly life, which a shravak tries to minimize and purify by right attitude.
- Weak immunity – is that pap?
- Having weak immunity is a result of many causes: past karmas, current lifestyle, environment, age, etc. - Jainism does not say: “If you fall sick, you are doing pap right now.” - The focus is: in whatever situation you are in, respond with right conduct: - take care of your body as an instrument for dharma, - avoid unnecessary harm in the process, - accept pain with patience and equanimity where you can.
- How to make this more dharmic in practice
- Take medicine only when truly needed, as advised by a good doctor. - Prefer options that cause less overall himsa when reasonably possible. - Maintain a simple, sattvic Jain diet, proper sleep, and self‑discipline so that sickness itself reduces over time. - Before/after taking medicine, you can do pratikraman / repentance: - mentally say, “If any violence is caused through this, I ask for forgiveness and wish to reduce such violence day by day.” - Use regained health for sadhana, seva, and punya – not for more indulgence.
So:
- Yes, from the strict material view, killing pathogens is a kind of himsa.
- But for a householder, taking necessary medicine with right intention and care is not considered serious pap, and can even be associated with punya when it protects life and supports a dharmic, compassionate life.
You can read a simple explanation of punya–paap and their types here