Jain Knowledge
Menu
  • JainGPT
  • Jain Directory
    • Jain Tirthsthaans
    • Jain Sangeetkars
    • Jain Pandits
    • Jain Acharya
    • Jain Businessman
  • Jain Media
    • Jain Stavan
    • Jain Pachkhan
    • Jain Stories
    • Jain Sutras
    • Jain Facts / Concepts
  • Advertise with us
Jain Knowledge
login Register

Get In Touch

phone
info@jainknowledge.com

online support

phone
Mumbai

India

  • Home
  • Jain Questions
  • so tirthankar walked doing himsa to ekindriya jeev but he did not stop a panchindriya jeev from killing and injuring another panchindriya jeev as it is himsa. is this right?
  • author Posted by
    Jain Follower

    so tirthankar walked doing himsa to ekindriya jeev but he did not stop a panchindriya jeev from killing and injuring another panchindriya jeev as it is himsa. is this right?

    4 months ago 54

    In Jain understanding, yes, there is a difference.

    • A Tirthankar’s walking may cause very subtle himsa to ekindriya jivas in the physical sense, because worldly activity cannot be completely free from injury.
    • But a Tirthankar has no raga-dvesha, no attachment, and no negligent intention. So there is no karmic bondage like in ordinary beings.

    For the second part:

    • A Tirthankar does teach ahimsa and truth.
    • But not stopping every panchendriya jeev by force is not the same as approving violence.
    • In Jain dharma, himsa is chiefly bound to intention, negligence, and participation through mind, speech, or body.
    • A Tirthankar does not become responsible for another being’s violence just because he did not physically intervene in every case.

    So the correct understanding is:

    1. Physical injury without attachment and intention is not the same as sinful himsa in the Jain karmic sense.
    2. Allowing others to act according to their own karma is different from encouraging or intending violence.
    3. A Tirthankar’s role is to preach the path of ahimsa, not to forcibly control every being.

    So your statement is partly right, but it needs refinement:

    • Yes, even saintly movement may involve unavoidable subtle injury.
    • No, it does not mean the Tirthankar is morally equal to one who commits violence through passion, negligence, or approval.

    In Jain terms, bhav-himsa and dravya-himsa are not the same. The Tirthankar is beyond bhav-himsa.

    About Jain Knowledge

    JainGPT by JainKnowledge.com is India’s first AI-powered platform dedicated entirely to Jainism. Here, you can ask any question related to Jain Dharma — from rituals and history to philosophy and daily practices — and receive instant, accurate answers rooted in Jain principles.

    Our mission is to make Jain knowledge accessible to all, especially the next generation, through the power of technology. Whether you're a curious student or a lifelong seeker, JainGPT is your trusted digital guide for all things Jain.

    Authentic Jain knowledge, made simple and accessible for every generation.
    Follow Us
    Facebook ↗ Instagram ↗

    Stay connected for Jain knowledge, insights and community updates.

    Jain Knowledge

    JainGPT by JainKnowledge.com is India’s first AI-powered platform dedicated entirely to Jainism. Ask questions related to Jain Dharma, rituals, history, philosophy and daily practices, and receive answers rooted in Jain principles.

    Explore
    • JainGPT
    • Jain Directory
    • Jain Media
    • Advertise With Us
    • Disclaimer
    Our Mission

    Our mission is to make Jain knowledge accessible to all, especially the next generation, through the power of technology. Whether you're a curious student or a lifelong seeker, JainGPT is your trusted digital guide for all things Jain.

    info@jainknowledge.com Online support
    Mumbai India

    Copyright © 2026 Jain Knowledge

    Created by Katalyst Corp.