How is not eating onions saving germs while taking planes is not a sin
In Jainism, the idea is not about “saving germs”. It is about minimizing हिंसा (violence) and avoiding foods or actions that involve a greater amount of injury or increase passions.
Why onions are avoided
Onion is avoided because:- it is a root vegetable, so harvesting it destroys the whole plant and many living beings in the soil,
- it is believed to increase passions, agitation, and attachment,
- it is considered unsuitable for a life of sattva, restraint, and purity.
So the main reason is ahimsa and spiritual discipline, not “protecting germs.”
Why flying in a plane is not automatically a sin
In Jainism, many actions in worldly life involve some degree of harm. A householder cannot live with perfect monk-like renunciation.Flying in a plane is generally seen as:
- not done with the intention to kill,
- usually done for necessity, duty, health, or important work,
- accepted as part of limited worldly life, where one tries to reduce harm as much as possible.
The Jain principle
Jain ethics does not say:- “Only some violence is sin and other violence is pure.”
Rather, it says:
- violence should be avoided as much as possible,
- if unavoidable, it should be done with care, restraint, repentance, and minimum harm.
So:
- Not eating onions is a voluntary act of restraint and nonviolence.
- Taking a plane may involve unavoidable worldly activity, so it is not condemned in the same way, especially for a layperson.
In short: Onions are avoided because they are a chosen, unnecessary form of harmful food, while flying is often considered a necessary worldly act with unavoidable violence.