how can matter change without karma or karta?
Answer
In Jainism, matter changes by its own nature and through conditions, not because a conscious soul is acting as the doer.Explanation
In Jain philosophy, pudgala (matter) is a real substance with its own qualities and modes. It is naturally subject to parinama — transformation or change.So matter changes because:
- it has an inherent nature to transform,
- it is influenced by time, space, and other conditions,
- it undergoes change through its own material cause.
This does not mean a soul must be the karta of that change.
Important Jain distinction
- Karta in the strict spiritual sense refers to the soul when it acts with consciousness and intention.
- Matter does not have consciousness, so it does not act like a soul.
- Matter simply changes state according to its own nature.
About karma
In Jainism, karma is also a form of subtle matter. So karma itself changes and binds according to laws of causation. But that does not mean a conscious soul is personally creating every material change in the universe.Spiritual Understanding
This teaching helps us understand that:- the soul and matter are distinct,
- the soul is responsible for conscious bondage and liberation,
- matter follows its own natural transformations.
When we correctly understand this, we stop confusing the soul with non-living substance. That clarity is very important in Jain Dharma.