Answer

Jain drishti se, Jin puja with kudrishti aur mithyadev pooja with shaant-karuna bhaav dono ka phal ek jaisa nahi hota.

• Jin puja ka mool adhar sahi dev — yani Arihant / Jin — hain.
• Shaant-karuna bhaav bahut punya-karak hota hai, lekin mithyadev ke prati pooja ka spiritual moolya Jinpuja ke samaan nahi hota.
• Kudrishti ke saath Jinpuja karne se bhi, Jin ke prati sambandh hone ke kaaran, usme kuch punya ho sakta hai; par badha hua phal tab aata hai jab samyak drishti aur shuddh bhav ho.

Explanation

Jain dharma me bhav bahut mahatvapurn hai, lekin bhav aur vishay dono ka sahi hona chahiye.

1) Jinpuja with kudrishti

• Yahan object sahi hai: Jin Bhagwan.
• Par drishti / samajh poori tarah shuddh nahi.
• Isse:

- kuch punya-bandh ho sakta hai, - man ko shanti mil sakti hai, - par moksha-marg ka full fayda nahi milta.

2) Mithyadev pooja with shaant-karuna bhaav

• Yahan bhav soft aur karunamay hai.
• Isse bhi:

- man me namrata, - shanti, - aur kuch punya ban sakta hai.

• Lekin kyunki pooja ka vishay mithyadev hai, isliye Jain drishti se yeh Jinpuja jaisa adhyatmik phal nahi deta.

Spiritual Understanding

Jain dharma me samyak darshan sabse mahatvapurn hai.

• Sahi dev = Arihant/Jin
• Sahi shastra = Jain Agam
• Sahi guru = samyak charitra wale sadhu-sadhvi

Isliye:

• Sirf shaant bhaav kaafi nahi hota.
• Sirf ritual bhi kaafi nahi hota.
• Sahi vishay + sahi bhav + sahi drishti milkar pooja ko sarvottam banate hain.

Agar simple comparison karein:

• Jinpuja with kudrishti = sahi lakshya, par drishti kamzor
• Mithyadev pooja with shaant-karuna bhaav = bhav achha, par lakshya galat

Jain marg me sahi lakshya ko hi adhik mahatva diya jata hai.

Takeaway

Shaant-karuna bhaav bahut achha hai, par Jinpuja ka asli phal tabhi puri tarah milta hai jab samyak drishti ho. Aur mithyadev pooja me bhav pious ho sakta hai, lekin Jinpuja ke barabar nahi mana jata.

Agar aap chahen, main isko aur bhi simple table comparison me likh sakta hoon.