if karma cannot be transferred from one person to another how it it possible that praying or doing tap for someone else works?
Answer
In Jain Dharma, karma is not transferred from one soul to another. So when we pray for someone or do tapa for someone, it does not mean their karma has moved to us or that our karma has moved to them.What it can do is:
- create punya and purity in the one who prays or तपस्या करता है,
- create auspicious support for the other person,
- become a nimitta or helping cause for their inner change,
- strengthen shubha bhavna and compassionate connection.
Explanation
Jain philosophy says every soul is bound by its own karma and must experience the results of that karma itself. No one can literally take away another person’s karma.But prayer and tapa still matter because they work in an indirect way:
- Your prayer changes your own inner state
- Your tapa creates your own punya
- The other person may receive inspiration and strength
So the effect is not “karma transfer.” It is spiritual support, merit, and supportive causes.
Spiritual Understanding
This is very important in Jain Dharma because it preserves the truth of self-responsibility.- No one can save us by taking our karma away.
- No one can suffer our karma in our place.
- But others can help us through good intentions, blessings, guidance, and supportive conduct.
That is why Jainism values:
- self-effort
- right faith
- right conduct
- compassionate support for others
Prayer for others is meaningful because it creates purity in the heart and becomes a noble supportive cause, not because karma is physically transferred.