But isn't it said that these are not same as the vegetables and are more than 3 days so can be considered
Answer
In Jain Dharma, being “more than 3 days old” does not automatically make something acceptable.
If you are referring to items like sprouted grains, fermented foods, pickles, stored foods, or items with microbial growth, then the Jain concern is not only whether they are “vegetables,” but whether they involve:
- growth of living organisms,
- fermentation,
- decay or decomposition,
- increase of subtle life forms,
- or avoidable harm to living beings.
So even if they are not the same as ordinary vegetables, they may still be avoided depending on the item and the Jain tradition followed.
Explanation
The “3-day” idea is usually discussed in relation to freshness, storage, and increase of living organisms in food. But it is not a universal rule that says:
“After 3 days, the item becomes acceptable.”
Rather, Jain food discipline is based on Ahimsa, carefulness, and avoiding foods where life forms may multiply or where violence is considered higher.
For example:
- Fresh vegetables are one category.
- Root vegetables are avoided by many Jains because uprooting destroys the whole plant and many organisms around it.
- Fermented or stale items may be avoided because of growth of countless subtle organisms.
- Sprouted items may be treated carefully because sprouting indicates active growth and life development.
So the question is not simply: “Is it a vegetable?” The deeper Jain question is: “Does consuming this involve avoidable harm or growth/destruction of living beings?”
Spiritual Understanding
Jain Dharma teaches that food should be chosen with vivek—spiritual discrimination. The aim is not just following a technical rule, but reducing himsa as much as possible.
Different Jain families, sects, and levels of practice may observe these rules differently. Some follow stricter rules, especially during Paryushan, Ayambil, Upvas, Chauvihar, or other tapasya.
Takeaway
If an item is old, fermented, sprouted, decaying, or life-generating, then it should not be considered acceptable merely because it is “not the same as vegetables” or because it is “more than 3 days old.” In Jain Dharma, the main principle is always Ahimsa with carefulness.