You are right to point that out.

The Nav Smaran commonly recited in the Tapagacch tradition are different from the Nav Smaran of Achalgachh. It is important not to mix them, because different Jain gacch traditions may preserve different smaran, stavan, or ritual recitation lineages.

Answer

Yes, the Tapagacch Nav Smaran should be identified separately and should not be presented as Achalgachh Nav Smaran.

Explanation

In Jain tradition, especially among Śvetāmbara Mūrtipūjak communities, different gacch traditions such as:

• Tapagacch
• Achalgachh
• Kharatargachh
• Tristutik Gachh

may have differences in certain devotional recitations, ritual procedures, guru-paramparā references, and traditional smaran texts.

So if a text belongs to Tapagacch Nav Smaran, it should not be labeled as Achalgachh Nav Smaran unless that is clearly verified within that tradition.

Spiritual Understanding

Jain Dharma gives great importance to śraddhā, vinay, and authentic tradition. Preserving the correct name, lineage, and usage of a sacred recitation is part of respecting the guru-paramparā.

Takeaway

Thank you for the correction. The proper distinction should be maintained: Tapagacch Nav Smaran is not the same as Achalgachh Nav Smaran.