Answer

In Jain practice, during Nam Jap of the Navkar Mantra, it is generally better to avoid using the index finger for counting on a mala.

Traditionally, the mala is moved using the thumb and middle finger, while the index finger is kept away.

Explanation

The index finger is often associated with ego, pointing, and worldly assertion. Since Navkar Mantra Jap is a practice of humility, surrender, and reverence toward the Panch Parmesthi, many traditions avoid using the index finger while doing mantra jap.

A common method is:

• Hold the mala gently in the right hand.
• Use the thumb to move the beads.
• Use the middle finger to support and rotate the beads.
• Avoid crossing the meru bead if your mala has one; instead, reverse direction.

Spiritual Understanding

Navkar Mantra is not merely repetition of words. It is a practice of inner purification, humility, and focus on the supreme qualities of Arihant, Siddha, Acharya, Upadhyay, and Sadhu.

Avoiding the index finger helps maintain a devotional and disciplined attitude during jap.

Takeaway

Yes, you may still receive spiritual benefit if done with sincere devotion, but traditionally, it is best to avoid using the index finger and use the thumb and middle finger for Navkar Mantra Jap.