Isnt there a nuance when we consider the dietary restrictions like we dont eat any fermented foods like curd and stuff but milk is allowed onions are not allowed because there are so called ekendriya organisms in em which have soul but in the same setting
Answer
Yes, there is an important nuance here.
In Jain Dharma, the traditional allowance of milk was based on a very different social setting: cows and other animals were generally cared for in household or pastoral environments, and milk was taken without the kind of industrial cruelty seen today.
So your concern is valid: if milk is obtained through violence, exploitation, separation of calves, confinement, or suffering, then a Jain should seriously question its use.
From the Jain principle of Ahimsa, knowingly supporting avoidable suffering of a higher-sensed living being is spiritually serious.
Explanation
Jain dietary discipline is not only about “what item is allowed or not allowed.” It is about reducing harm as much as possible.
Jain thought recognizes different levels of life:
- Ekendriya jivas — one-sensed beings, such as earth-bodied, water-bodied, fire-bodied, air-bodied, and plant-bodied beings.
- Tras jivas — mobile beings with two to five senses, such as insects, animals, and humans.
Harming a five-sensed being, especially one capable of fear, pain, attachment, and distress, is considered much more serious than harm to one-sensed beings.
This is why your point is meaningful: if one avoids onions, potatoes, or fermented foods due to concern for subtle life, but ignores the suffering of cows and calves in modern dairy production, that would be ethically inconsistent from the standpoint of Jain Ahimsa.
Traditional Jain Position
Traditionally, milk, curd, ghee, and similar dairy items have been used in many Jain communities, including in food, medicine, and certain religious contexts.
However, this traditional acceptance does not mean that any milk obtained by any method is automatically free from himsa.
The moral issue depends greatly on:
- How the animal is treated
- Whether the calf is deprived
- Whether the animal is forcibly impregnated or exploited
- Whether the animal is confined, injured, or eventually slaughtered
- Whether our consumption increases demand for such practices
If cruelty is involved, then the karmic and ethical concern becomes very real.
About Curd and Fermented Foods
One small correction: in many Jain communities, curd is traditionally consumed under certain restrictions, especially when fresh and properly prepared. But stale, overly fermented, or night-kept foods are generally avoided by many observant Jains because fermentation increases the growth of countless microorganisms.
Different Jain traditions and levels of observance may vary in practice.
So it is not always accurate to say “Jains do not eat curd at all.” Some do; some avoid it; and many observe rules about freshness and timing.
Spiritual Understanding
Jain Dharma does not ask us merely to follow a food list mechanically. It asks us to cultivate sensitivity.
The deeper question is:
- Am I reducing harm?
- Am I consuming out of necessity or attachment?
- Am I supporting violence indirectly?
- Can I choose a less harmful alternative?
If a person concludes that modern dairy involves serious himsa, choosing to avoid milk and dairy can be seen as a sincere expression of Ahimsa, provided it is done with humility and without pride or judgment toward others.
Takeaway
Your concern is not against Jain Dharma; it is very much within the spirit of Jain Dharma.
Traditional Jainism allowed dairy in a different context, but modern factory farming raises serious Ahimsa concerns. A thoughtful Jain should not turn a blind eye to suffering. Reducing or avoiding such dairy, when possible, can be a meaningful step toward deeper compassion and non-violence.