if jain don't want himsa then jain ner should do business, it always leads to more himsa than ahimsa
You’ve touched a very important and practical doubt. I’ll keep the reply simple and fully within Jain principles.
1. Two levels in Jainism: Sadhu vs Gṛhastha
- Sādhu / Sādhvī (monk/nun) – Ideal: complete ahimsa, no business, no money, no possessions.
- Gṛhastha (householder Jain) – Lives in society, earns, runs family, does business/job, but with limited vows (Anuvrat) and tries to minimise himsa, not eliminate it fully.
So, Jain Dharma never says: “Householder must do zero himsa like a monk.” It says: “Householder must reduce and control himsa as much as possible and keep moving towards ahimsa.”
2. Is business equal to “only himsa”?
Not necessarily.
Wrong view: “Any business = more himsa than ahimsa, so Jains should not do business.”
Jain view:
- Some businesses are high-himsa (meat, leather, weapons, fishing, pesticides, intoxicants etc.) → strongly discouraged. ( jainknowledge.com)
- Many businesses can be done with less himsa, and with right intention and careful methods, himsa can be greatly reduced. ( jainknowledge.com)
Examples of usually lower-himsa or more suitable work for a Jain:
- Education, teaching, coaching
- Software, design, consulting, accounting
- Ethical trading, eco-friendly products, organic/vegan items
- Healthcare done with compassion and care
3. What do Jain scriptures actually teach?
For householders, scriptures talk about Right Livelihood – Samyak Ājīva:
- Earn by honest, non-deceitful, and as-nonviolent-as-possible means. ( jainknowledge.com)
- Avoid five types of trades that involve clear, strong violence:
They do not say: “Don’t work or don’t do any business.” They say: “Do business with ahimsa, satya, asteya, aparigraha in mind.”
You can read more on Jain business guidance here
4. Why business can also support ahimsa
If done properly, business can:
- Provide fair livelihood to employees (no exploitation).
- Support charities, animal care, education, Jain temples, pathshalas etc.
- Promote ahimsa-based products (vegetarian/vegan, cruelty-free, eco-friendly). ( jainknowledge.com)
This doesn’t remove all karma, but:
- Intention + careful choices + limits on greed = much less paap, more punya.
5. Practical Jain way for you
If you are a Jain and must earn:
- Choose the right field
- Avoid obvious high-himsa trades. - Prefer services, knowledge work, or ethical products.
- Run it with vows in mind
- Ahimsa: avoid unnecessary killing, cruelty, wastage. - Satya: no cheating, fake promises, manipulation. - Asteya: no hidden charges, no tax theft, no exploitation. - Aparigraha: set limits on profit and lifestyle; don’t let greed rule.
- Use profit rightly
- Part for family duty, part for seva, daan, dharma.
So, according to Jain Dharma, a Jain can do business. The goal is not “no action”, but right action with minimum possible himsa, and keep progressing step by step towards higher ahimsa.